It’s a common misconception that being in second place means being a mere footnote in the story of success. The term also-ran exemplifies this notion, reducing those who finish behind the winners to an indistinct group, as if their efforts are less valuable. This perspective often leads to the dismissal of remarkable achievements that deserve recognition but are often overshadowed by more prominent contenders. In the world of music, this sentiment rings especially true, as many legendary artists find themselves in the shadow of their peers despite producing exceptional work.

Take, for example, the iconic Mick Jagger, who openly reflected on the Rolling Stones’ place in music history and acknowledged the overwhelming popularity of the Beatles during a pivotal era. His poignant remark, “That’s us,” highlights the pressure to excel when you’re perceived as No. 2. This competitive landscape fuels a drive for improvement, yet it simultaneously casts a long shadow over the artistic contributions of those who came in second.

When examining best-album lists, it’s evident that the winners dominate the conversation. Albums like the Stones’ Exile on Main St., the Doors’ debut, the Allman Brothers Band’s At Fillmore East, and Pink Floyd’s The Dark Side of the Moon are frequently celebrated. However, this repetitive selection often neglects the rich tapestry of music that lies just beyond these acclaimed records, overshadowed by their more famous counterparts. The focus on the top-tier albums can create a narrow view of musical excellence.

READ MORE: Yes, They Actually Wore This in the ’80s

Yet, what about those outstanding albums that exist in the shadows of these celebrated masterpieces? These works often provide crucial context and appreciation for the artists’ broader careers. A continual emphasis on iconic albums can obscure the hard work, creativity, and consistent quality of the albums that, while not the primary focus, still boast tremendous artistic merit.

The reality is that the so-called runner-up albums from many of music’s most beloved groups are nothing short of extraordinary. They may not have claimed the coveted top spot, but as our list of Classic Rock’s Second Best Albums illustrates, these records are undeniably valuable contributions to the music landscape, showcasing creativity and artistry that deserves to be recognized and celebrated.

Discover Why Some Artists Disliked Their Own Work