Editor’s note: The below recap contains spoilers for Bad Sisters Season 2 Episode 4.

Every time the Garvey sisters believe they have escaped from one chaotic situation, they find themselves plunged into yet another dilemma. The Bad Sisters are still mourning their sister Grace (Anne-Marie Duff), but they quickly realize that they don’t have the luxury of time to grieve, as a new threat emerges in the form of Angelica (Fiona Shaw). True to the Garvey sisters’ track record, their attempts to safeguard their secrets end in disaster. This leaves them grappling with the question: can they outsmart the police while simultaneously evading Angelica’s grasp?

The Garveys Develop a Strategic Approach in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

The episode kicks off with Becka (Eve Hewson) attending a performance featuring Matt’s (Daryl McCormack) band. During this event, Detective Una Houlihan (Thaddea Graham) approaches Becka at the bar, reminding her that she remains a person of interest in John Paul’s murder investigation. She pressures Becka for details regarding her relationship with Matt, implying ulterior motives behind their connection. However, Becka skillfully chooses to remain silent. After the performance, Matt expresses his lingering distress over the chaos that followed John Paul’s death, stating, “I risked everything for you.” In a biting retort, Becka replies, “Well, my sister’s dead now, so you shouldn’t have bothered.” The tension escalates, and Becka’s physical state worsens; initially thought to be a result of alcohol, it’s soon revealed that she has purchased several pregnancy tests, indicating there’s more to her nausea than meets the eye.

The Sisters Confront Angelica and Concoct a Plan in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

The following day, the sisters gather at the beach, where they spot Angelica collecting litter along the shore. She boldly claims that Grace confided in her about everything, prompting an explosive reaction from Becka, who accuses Angelica of being a “stage 5 clinger,” asserting that it’s precisely why Grace had to distance herself. Ursula (Eva Birthistle) further exacerbates the situation by blaming Angelica for Grace’s demise. However, Angelica strikes back with a painful truth: “Shame drove Grace to her death, not me.” To strategize their next move, the sisters retreat to a sauna, where Becka proposes breaking into Angelica’s home to uncover the money Grace had withdrawn, which they suspect was used to blackmail Angelica. Ursula expresses disbelief over being in yet another precarious situation due to Grace’s choices, lamenting how her sister could bring such chaos into their lives. Bibi (Sarah Greene) and Becka volunteer for the break-in, while Eva (Sharon Horgan) urges them to proceed with caution, warning them to leave no trace behind, foreshadowing potential trouble ahead.

Dramatic Events Unfold at the Camogie Match in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

At a camogie match for Blanaid (Saise Quinn), Eva witnesses Angelica gifting the teenager a new helmet, a gesture that indicates her increasing involvement in their lives. The match quickly escalates when Eva and Ian (Owen McDonnell) share a flirtatious moment, but the atmosphere turns sour when another player taunts Blanaid, asking, “Which one of your family’s gonna die next?” This incites Blanaid to push the girl, igniting a violent brawl. The situation worsens when Ursula’s daughter, Molly (Kate Higgins), suffers severe injuries, resulting in several knocked-out teeth, leading to Molly blaming Blanaid for instigating the chaos.

Tension Builds as the Sisters Prepare for a Break-In in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

Meanwhile, Ursula is stationed outside a church as a lookout for the break-in, keeping tabs on Angelica’s movements. Roger (Michael Smiley) approaches her, suggesting they meet for a date, inspired by Grace’s death to take more risks in life. Just as Ursula is about to respond, she receives an urgent call from her ex-husband about Molly’s injury, prompting her to abandon her post and rush to the scene. This leads to rising tensions between Eva and Ursula, fueled by the high-pressure situation.

The Sisters Infiltrate Angelica’s Home and Uncover Dark Secrets in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

Inside Angelica’s home, Bibi and Becka manage to break in through an open window. As they search through Angelica’s belongings, they come across evidence that suggests she played a role in her husband’s departure before his death, revealing he had left her for another woman. This starkly contrasts with Angelica’s earlier claims about her grief to Ursula in Episode 3. They also discover that Angelica was involved in a homophobic protest with her church, hinting at her complicated past. To add to the bizarre atmosphere, the sisters find live bunnies hidden in Angelica’s closet, and even more unsettling, a bedroom decorated for a teenage girl containing Blanaid’s school jacket. This revelation horrifies Becka, who runs to the bathroom to vomit just as Angelica unexpectedly returns home. Bibi escapes, but Becka finds herself trapped in the bathroom. After a tense moment, she makes a desperate dash past Angelica to flee the house. Once they are safely away, Bibi reveals she took one of the bunnies, but it quickly hops off into the underbrush, leaving them both rattled by the encounter.

The Police Close In on the Garvey Sisters in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

Detective Houlihan enthusiastically shares her findings about the Garvey sisters with Detective Inspector Fergal Loftus (Barry Ward), who is preoccupied with a personal issue involving his ex-wife and child custody disputes. Houlihan informs Loftus that all the Garveys stayed in a hotel near the murder scene on the night John Paul was killed. However, Loftus reaffirms the legal limitations, stating, “We can’t charge them… as long as they keep their mouths shut, they’re safe.” This precarious situation shifts dramatically when Angelica accuses Becka of breaking into her home and assaulting her during the incident, putting the sisters at greater risk.

Angelica Manipulates the Situation in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

In a scene at her home, Angelica is seen in bed, donning an oversized neck brace, while Roger tends to her. She feigns ignorance about the situation, claiming, “I just don’t know what I did to deserve this. I’m kind to a fault.” Roger, however, reveals the darker side of the sisters’ past, explaining to Angelica that John Paul raped Eva and emphasizing that the sisters are merely protecting each other. This revelation adds layers to Angelica’s manipulative tactics and her understanding of the sisters’ dynamics.

The Garvey Sisters Devise a Desperate Plan in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

Following Becka’s arrest stemming from Angelica’s allegations, the sisters convene at Eva’s house to formulate a strategy. They attempt to persuade Angelica to retract her complaint, but tensions heighten when Bibi accuses her of ‘grooming’ Blanaid. Eva and Ursula manage to steer the discussion back on course, appealing to Angelica’s religious beliefs and urging her to consider the consequences of her actions. Eva underscores the emotional toll by stating, “We’ve already lost one sister. We don’t want to lose another.” In a shocking twist, Angelica proposes that she will drop her complaint if they allow her to scatter Grace’s ashes, leaving the sisters in disbelief at the ultimatum.

Becka Faces the Ultimate Test in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

Under intense interrogation by the police regarding John Paul’s death, Becka strives to maintain her composure and evade the investigators’ probing questions. However, the situation takes a grim turn when they threaten her with a lengthy prison sentence for being an accessory to murder. In a moment of panic, Becka makes a critical error by suggesting that the police should focus on the circumstances surrounding Grace’s death, inadvertently revealing her knowledge of Grace’s suspicious financial activities. This slip could provide the detectives with a significant lead, placing the sisters in an even more precarious position.

The Garvey Sisters Find Themselves in a Perilous Situation in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

Becka is ultimately released from police custody, but the relief is short-lived as she learns of Angelica’s demands. Although the sisters are determined to reject her ultimatum, Becka reveals her pregnancy to Eva, a confession that brings additional emotional weight to her already strained situation. In a moment of vulnerability, she exits Eva’s car, seeking solace from Matt instead of her boyfriend. Their shared history leads to a passionate kiss, as they confront the complexities of their relationship. However, when Becka encounters Joe (Peter Claffey), he pleads for a second chance, but she ultimately decides to end things with him, leaving him heartbroken while Matt appears hopeful for a potential rekindling of their romance.

Ian Issues a Warning to Angelica in ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 Episode 4

The episode closes with Ian confronting Angelica outside her church, issuing a stern warning to stay away from the Garvey sisters. Despite his bravado, he seems blissfully unaware of the manipulative nature of Angelica, who thrives on intimidation. Ian’s misguided attempt to protect the sisters could very well backfire, exacerbating their already complicated predicament, as they navigate threats from both Angelica and the police.

New episodes of Bad Sisters Season 2 are available to stream every Wednesday on Apple TV+ in the U.S.

Bad Sisters Season 2 Episode 4 continues to raise the stakes for the Garveys.

Pros

• There are plenty of heart-pumping moments in this episode that provide great suspense.
• Eve Hewson gets several moments to shine because of Becka’s complicated life.
• Setting up a connection between Ian and Eva is unexpected and a fun development.

Cons

• Blanaid’s storyline of teenage angst is starting to feel a bit repetitive.

<div class="display-card screen tag large no-badge expandable " data-show-streamrentbuy-links="false" data-include-community-rating="false"