When The Agency was first announced on Showtime, it generated significant anticipation, suggesting it was poised to be a compelling addition to the spy thriller genre. This excitement is heightened by an exceptional ensemble cast that features Academy Award nominees Michael Fassbender and Jeffrey Wright, alongside the acclaimed writing duo of John-Henry and Jez Butterworth. The series is inspired by the critically acclaimed but often overlooked French series, The Bureau, which offered a more authentic and gritty exploration of espionage and spycraft than typical portrayals. This foundation sets the stage for a narrative that could resonate deeply with audiences seeking realism in a genre often filled with dramatized tropes.

Spy dramas have proven to be a stable presence on television, with shows like <em>Slow Horses</em> capturing audience attention for their intricate plots and character development. In this vein, The Agency seems to share a similar DNA with Apple TV+’s acclaimed series, hinting at a sophisticated narrative style. Remarkably, the production began filming just this past June, and now, only five months later, it is gearing up for a premiere during the Thanksgiving weekend. With all the right ingredients for success, including the use of Jack White’s evocative cover of “Love is Blindness” as the theme song, which suggests a deeper emotional vulnerability in Fassbender’s character, the anticipation is palpable. Nevertheless, there’s an underlying sense that something is amiss with The Agency, leaving viewers curious yet cautious about what’s to come.

Explore the Intriguing Premise of ‘The Agency’

The storyline follows CIA agent “Martian,” portrayed by Michael Fassbender, who has spent an extended period in Ethiopia, where he was embroiled in a tumultuous affair with a married college professor named Sami Zahir, played by Jodie Turner-Smith. As Martian receives orders to return to England, he faces the daunting task of abruptly severing ties with Sami, leading to a complex emotional landscape that is set to unfold as he boards a plane back to Europe. This initial setup not only establishes the personal stakes for Martian but also hints at the broader themes of loyalty, sacrifice, and the intricate balance between personal and professional life that will be explored throughout the series.

Upon his return to London Station, Martian struggles to adapt to civilian life, revealing a more mundane and relatable perspective on the often glorified world of CIA operations. The series introduces a dynamic work environment filled with bickering colleagues, particularly the contentious relationship between Director Henry, played by Jeffrey Wright, and Chief Bosko, portrayed by Richard Gere. As Martian attempts to keep a low profile, his plans are shattered by Sami’s unexpected reappearance, thrusting him into a tumultuous moral dilemma that forces him to choose between his professional commitments and his personal desires for love and connection.

While the premise of The Agency may sound engaging, it becomes evident that the series opts for a slower narrative pace, which can feel frustratingly sluggish at times. The first episode, in particular, seems to focus predominantly on character introductions rather than diving into the action and intrigue that one might expect from a spy thriller. Visually, however, The Agency captivates with its interesting aesthetic. Even simple scenes, such as Fassbender driving alongside either Wright’s Henry or Harriet Sansom Harris’ Dr. Blake, are surprisingly striking and visually pleasing, a testament to the skilled direction of Joe Wright, which undoubtedly contributes to the show’s overall appeal.

Related

Michael Fassbender’s ‘The Agency’ Just Got a Big Update

Fassbender stars in the remake of ‘The Bureau’.

Why ‘The Agency’ Seems to Play It Too Safe

The Agency had all the potential to become a standout series within the spy drama landscape. The decision by Showtime to adapt the original French series serves as a testament to the narrative’s inherent promise. However, this Americanized iteration appears to be playing it overly safe, often opting for conventional storytelling over bold exploration. While it is not a bad show by any measure—its direction is competent, and the cast delivers commendable performances—there’s a lingering sense that it could have ventured into more daring territory.

Jeffrey Wright’s performance as Henry emerges as a highlight of The Agency, showcasing the charm and intelligence that audiences have come to appreciate. Although his role does not offer much new, it is a classic portrayal that he excels in, characterized by directness and sharp intellect. Conversely, the portrayal of Martian, while enigmatic, shares similarities with some of Fassbender’s previous characters, particularly his role in The Killer. He embodies a character that is mysterious, strategic, and emotionally reserved, yet Fassbender’s compelling performance ensures that he remains intriguing to viewers. Turner-Smith, who has had a remarkable year with roles in The Acolyte and Bad Monkey, delivers one of her strongest performances yet as Sami Zahir. Although her character may initially seem underdeveloped, it is evident that she will bring more depth and intrigue as the series unfolds.

Despite the strong performances across the board, The Agency struggles to maintain viewer engagement due to its narrative shortcomings. While the series attempts to incorporate contemporary geopolitical themes, such as the ongoing Russo-Ukrainian War, it lacks a clear perspective or message. Name-dropping political figures like Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin fails to elicit genuine interest or provoke thought. It appears that the writers intended to provide a deeper commentary on surveillance and global diplomacy, yet they shy away from taking any strong positions, resulting in a narrative that feels superficial and lacking in substance.

Unpacking the Wasted Potential of ‘The Agency’

Despite its numerous strengths, The Agency ultimately presents a mixed bag of opportunities lost, as it struggles to find its identity between gritty realism and a more sensationalized spy narrative. Both approaches could have yielded compelling results, particularly given Martian’s unexpected reunion with Sami, which could lead to an engaging espionage tale filled with suspense, twists, and romantic tension. Furthermore, the series attempts to portray a realistic and mundane perspective on spycraft, echoing elements of a workplace drama where characters like John Magaro‘s Owen and Katherine Waterston‘s Naomi engage in complex communication with foreign assets. While The Agency acknowledges the high stakes inherent in its plot, it also appears to shy away from fully committing to any one narrative style, resulting in a diluted experience for viewers.

The most significant drawback of The Agency lies in its combination of intriguing concepts and characters that fail to coalesce into a memorable viewing experience. Despite the presence of a talented creative team and a star-studded cast, The Agency ultimately feels like a diluted imitation of superior spy dramas. Although the execution is competent, the series struggles to distinguish itself in a crowded genre. In a landscape filled with superior espionage television, viewers might find themselves reminiscing about Slow Horses or wishing that talented actors like Fassbender and Wright had been cast in more captivating roles, rather than navigating through a series that feels like a missed opportunity.

Ultimately, The Agency squanders its potential, hindered by slow pacing and a conflicted tone that never fully embraces either popcorn entertainment or a more profound narrative. Viewers are left wondering what could have been as the series grapples with its identity, making it difficult to engage with the story on a deeper level.

The Agency premieres November 29 on Paramount+ with Showtime.

Despite the best efforts of its talented cast, The Agency feels like a dull imitation of better spy shows.

Pros

• Michael Fassbender, Jeffrey Wright, and Jodie Turner-Smith all turn in compelling performances.
• The storyline between Fassbender and Turner-Smith’s characters is intriguing.

Cons

• The series struggles between whether it wants to be something more pulpy or grounded and realistic.
• The series wants to include real-world conflicts without taking a stance.
• The Agency fails to find a compelling hook to keep you invested in the story.

<div class="display-card screen tag large no-b