Ex-Megadeth Manager Wins Lawsuit Against Dave Mustaine

In a significant legal development, Megadeth frontman Dave Mustaine has reached a settlement in a lawsuit with his former manager, Cory Brennan, leading to a substantial payout amounting to over a million dollars. This agreement comes in the wake of Brennan’s claims for unpaid commissions following his termination from the management role in 2023, a position that was subsequently filled by Mustaine’s son, Justis Mustaine.

The settlement totals $1,400,006, which Mustaine disbursed to Brennan along with his management company, Five B Management. This information was disclosed publicly in a legal filing made on Wednesday, November 13. The resolution not only addresses financial claims but also highlights the complexities of artist-management relationships.

Understanding the Legal Dispute: Why Cory Brennan Filed a Lawsuit

Cory Brennan initiated legal proceedings against Dave Mustaine, asserting that the iconic musician had neglected to pay over $1 million in owed commissions. In a statement provided to Billboard, Brennan’s attorney, Howard King, expressed his client’s reluctance to take legal action against an artist he deeply respects but acknowledged the relief felt upon receiving the settlement. King remarked, “Brennan was displeased at having to sue an artist,” illustrating the emotional toll such disputes can take.

King further elaborated, noting that Mustaine had a history of severing ties with advisors, having dismissed Five B Artist Management after nearly a decade of collaboration that revitalized his career. This partnership contributed significantly to Mustaine’s achievements, including securing his first Grammy Award, releasing two successful albums, and elevating his performances from intimate venues to large arenas. King emphasized that despite these contributions, Mustaine failed to compensate for the commissions due, compelling Five B to pursue legal action.

Mustaine’s legal team contended that there was a pre-existing understanding that both parties would amicably “go their separate ways” after any termination, framing the lawsuit as a retaliatory measure. The defense claimed that Brennan’s dissatisfaction stemmed from the consequences of his alleged mismanagement of the band’s business affairs.

Exploring Remaining Disputes: What Issues Still Need Resolution

While the financial aspect of the dispute has been settled, several unresolved issues linger between Mustaine and Brennan. Notably, Mustaine countersued his former manager last year, asserting that Brennan’s management had been fraught with errors that significantly harmed his career and reputation. This highlights the ongoing complexities of their professional relationship.

Mustaine articulated that these alleged missteps not only tarnished Megadeth’s reputation in the music industry but also adversely affected his physical health, particularly his hearing. His claims extend beyond the commission dispute, encompassing serious allegations of breach of contract and negligence, which remain unresolved as litigation is set to continue.

READ MORE: The Cover Song Dave Mustaine Says Megadeth Will Never Play Again

As the legal battle progresses, the implications for both Mustaine and Brennan will be closely monitored by fans and industry observers alike, as they navigate the fallout from this high-profile dispute.