“What’s it about?” This question often arises with every television recommendation. In today’s extensive landscape of captivating TV shows, viewers want to ensure that their time and money are well spent on a series that truly delivers. They seek to determine whether a show’s premise resonates with previous favorites or offers a unique twist that piques their curiosity. A familiar premise can provide comfort and reassurance, while an innovative and offbeat idea can captivate audiences with unexpected plots and surprising developments. Both approaches have their merits, but ultimately, it’s the execution that determines a show’s success in engaging its audience.

HBO has earned a stellar reputation for producing some of the most remarkable television series in recent years, often leaning into bold and adventurous premises. From clever parodies to re-envisioned classic concepts, the network boasts an impressive lineup of shows with wildly imaginative descriptions. However, not every premise translates effectively into compelling storytelling, and of those that do, the quality can vary significantly. In this article, we evaluate and rank the HBO series with the most intriguing and original premises, focusing on how captivating they are and how well they deliver on their initial concept.

10 ‘The Comeback’ (2005–2014)

Explore the Creative Genius of Lisa Kudrow and Michael Patrick King

In the innovative series The Comeback, Lisa Kudrow made a remarkable return to television following her iconic role in Friends. Teaming up with Sex and the City executive producer Michael Patrick King, Kudrow crafted a satirical commentary on the television landscape that inadvertently became a prescient reflection on the rise of reality TV. Kudrow shines in her role as Valerie Cherish, an aging sitcom star attempting to revive her career on a new show. This performance is often overlooked but deserves recognition for its depth and nuance.

The first season, which aired before reality television took over mainstream entertainment, utilized a found footage format, presenting itself as footage for the in-show reality show that Valerie had agreed to participate in. The second season, which returned nearly a decade later amid reality TV’s dominance, maintains this found footage approach but shifts to a documentary style, capturing Valerie’s journey as she attempts to navigate the complexities of fame and personal relationships. Throughout its run, The Comeback brilliantly critiques both the scripted and reality television industries while also exploring profound themes such as aging, the intersection of personal and professional lives, and the nature of resilience.

Release Date

June 5, 2005

Seasons

2

WATCH ON MAX

9 ‘In Treatment’ (2008–2021)

Delve into the World of Therapy with Rodrigo Garcia’s Creation

In Treatment, based on the Israeli series BeTipul, stands out as a unique exploration of the therapeutic process. This groundbreaking show effectively rebooted itself after more than a decade, capturing the essence of a psychotherapist’s weekly sessions. The series begins with Paul Weston, portrayed by Gabriel Byrne, who conducts therapy sessions with his patients and concludes the week with his own therapy session led by Dianne Wiest in an Emmy-winning role, followed by Amy Ryan in the third season. In the fourth season, the narrative shifts to Uzo Aduba‘s character, Brooke Taylor, who navigates her own therapy as well as her struggles with addiction.

The show’s format offers an intimate exploration of mental health journeys, allowing viewers to witness the vulnerabilities and triumphs of the patients. This approach provides a more authentic representation of talk therapy, contrasting sharply with the sanitized portrayals often seen in films and TV. The series delves into the complexities of Paul and Brooke’s personal issues, showcasing the shared humanity in their struggles and the relatable imperfections of therapists, making it a profound commentary on mental health and recovery.

WATCH ON MAX

8 ‘Westworld’ (2016–2022)

Journey into the Complex Realities of Westworld by Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy

Westworld, inspired by Michael Crichton‘s iconic film, immerses viewers in a futuristic Wild West-themed amusement park where guests enjoy unrestricted access to lifelike androids. These androids, originally programmed to obey human commands, start to gain sentience after a software update, leading to a thrilling exploration of human-android relationships and the implications of artificial intelligence. The series expands upon Crichton’s original ideas, delving into themes of consciousness, morality, and the nature of reality.

Beyond the elements of artificial intelligence and autonomy, Westworld raises profound questions about the human condition, including the nature of violence, the complexities of memory, and the intricate dynamics of familial love. With its intertwining narratives, the series features a remarkable ensemble cast, including renowned actors like Anthony Hopkins, Ed Harris, and Thandiwe Newton, bringing depth to the multifaceted characters. The ambitious storytelling and philosophical underpinnings position Westworld as one of HBO’s most thought-provoking series.

WATCH ON MAX

7 ‘Barry’ (2018–2023)

Uncover the Dark Comedy of ‘Barry’ by Bill Hader and Alec Berg

Imagine a hitman who stumbles into an acting class and decides to stay; this is the intriguing premise of Bill Hader and Alec Berg‘s acclaimed dark comedy Barry. The series takes a seemingly straightforward idea and transforms it into a deep exploration of morality, identity, and the consequences of violence, while also addressing themes of ambition and PTSD. With its sharp wit and profound insights, Barry skillfully critiques the military-industrial complex and the entertainment industry, showcasing a rich tapestry of flawed characters.

Under the guidance of Bill Hader, who directed the majority of the episodes, Barry evolves from a dark comedy into a gripping examination of its characters’ moral decay. The series garnered critical acclaim, winning multiple Emmy Awards, including Best Actor for Hader and Best Supporting Actor for Henry Winkler. With nominations for Best Comedy Series and Best Writing, Barry stands out as one of HBO’s finest offerings, showcasing exceptional storytelling and character development.

WATCH ON MAX

6 ‘Lovecraft Country’ (2020)

Explore the Intersection of Horror and History in ‘Lovecraft Country’ by Misha Green