Ranked Performances of All 6 Main Actors in Gladiator 2
WARNING: SPOILERS ahead for Gladiator II.
Ridley Scott’s highly anticipated sequel, Gladiator II, showcases remarkable performances from an outstanding ensemble cast, spearheaded by Paul Mescal in the role of Lucius. As the film gears up for its theatrical release on November 22, 2024, it has garnered mostly favorable reviews, achieving a Certified Fresh score of 71% on Rotten Tomatoes. The star-studded cast includes Pedro Pascal, Denzel Washington, and Connie Nielsen, reprising her role as Lucilla, the mother of Mescal’s Lucius. The film made a splash at the box office, raking in an impressive $50 million during its opening weekend, positioning it to potentially become one of Ridley Scott’s highest-grossing films.
Although early audience reactions to Gladiator II do not suggest the same level of Oscar buzz as its predecessor, the film remains a contender for several prestigious awards, including Best Picture, Best Actor, and Best Supporting Actor for Denzel Washington. Critics have praised Gladiator II for its connection to the original action classic, despite the fact that Oscar-winning actor Russell Crowe, who portrayed Maximus, only appears in flashback sequences. Set approximately 16 years after the events of Gladiator, the sequel introduces a new scene that extends the original film’s conclusion while shedding light on why Lucilla and Maximus’s son, Lucius, has been separated.
Despite its somewhat predictable plot that occasionally feels like a remake rather than a true sequel, Gladiator II has successfully entertained audiences. However, some viewers have noted inconsistencies in the accents of characters like Mescal’s Lucius, Washington’s Macrinus, and Pascal’s Acadius, which can lead to confusion. Nevertheless, the film has emerged as one of the biggest cinematic events of 2024, expanding upon the legacy of the original Best Picture winner and potentially paving the way for a thrilling action trilogy. Ridley Scott has expressed no intention of stepping away from directing, promising exciting developments for his ongoing blockbuster franchises, including Alien and Blade Runner.
Gladiator II
is now playing in theaters.
6 Fred Hechinger
Explore Fred Hechinger’s Role as Emperor Caracalla
Fred Hechinger takes on the role of Emperor Caracalla in Gladiator II, portraying one of the two Roman Emperors alongside his brother, Emperor Geta. Their reign highlights their unfitness for the throne, a fact that becomes glaringly evident through their hedonistic and reckless behavior. Caracalla’s character is depicted as unpredictable and impulsive, contrasting sharply with his more composed brother. Hechinger first garnered attention with his feature film debut in Bo Burnham’s coming-of-age film Eighth Grade, later appearing in acclaimed series and films like The White Lotus, Fear Street, and Vox Lux before securing his role in Gladiator II.
Although Hechinger’s portrayal of Caracalla comes across as somewhat one-dimensional, it effectively captures the character’s obnoxious and despicable traits, especially as the story progresses. By the film’s conclusion, Caracalla essentially becomes a pawn in Macrinus’s scheme, lacking the depth seen in Joaquin Phoenix’s Commodus from the original Gladiator. While Hechinger effectively conveys his character’s foolishness, the repetitive nature of Caracalla’s character might have benefited from a more seasoned actor’s touch, allowing for a richer portrayal.
5 Connie Nielson
Discover Connie Nielson’s Impactful Return as Lucilla
Connie Nielson’s role as Lucilla is pivotal, serving as a crucial bridge between the original Gladiator and its sequel. Lucilla, now married to Pedro Pascal’s Marcus Acacius, stands as a powerful figure in Rome, having survived without the protection of her brother Commodus or the father of her child, Maximus. As the mother of Mescal’s Lucius and the daughter of Marcus Aurelius, Lucilla brings essential continuity to the sequel, making her one of the most significant characters in the plot of Gladiator II.
While Nielson’s return as Lucilla adds depth to the story, her character’s role is arguably not as central as expected. In the original, Lucilla was instrumental in Maximus’s journey toward freedom and revenge, a theme she continues in the sequel by guiding Lucius and opposing the Roman Emperors. Although Nielson’s portrayal remains strong, it is somewhat underwhelming. Lucilla’s character could have wielded more influence in the sequel, yet she is often relegated to a more formal role as seen in the original. While Nielson’s performance is filled with compassion and stoicism, Lucilla occasionally feels flat and lacks the dynamism one might hope for.
4 Joseph Quinn
Analyze Joseph Quinn’s Role as Emperor Geta
Joseph Quinn shines as Emperor Geta in Gladiator II, showcasing his potential as a formidable ruler, distinct from his chaotic brother. Known for his roles in series like Dickensian and Stranger Things, Quinn’s portrayal of Geta demonstrates a subtle balance of poise and menace. He brings depth to the character, suggesting that Geta could command authority without the erratic volatility of Caracalla. His past work, including A Quiet Place: Day One, positions him as a rising star in the industry.
Quinn’s performance as Geta offers a strong and believable depiction of an Emperor, which is unfortunately limited by the constraints of the role. Despite his character’s potential for villainy, the script does not fully exploit his capabilities. Unlike Phoenix’s Commodus, whose presence dominated the original film, Quinn’s Geta feels underutilized, leaving audiences wanting more. While Quinn delivers one of the strongest performances in Gladiator II, his limited screen time hinders a lasting impact on the narrative.
3 Paul Mescal
Unpack Paul Mescal’s Performance as Lucius
Paul Mescal stands out as one of the most talented young actors of his generation, gaining recognition for his role in the acclaimed series Normal People. His performance in celebrated films like All of Us Strangers and Aftersun earned him a Best Actor nomination, showcasing his range and emotional depth. However, some critics have expressed concerns regarding his casting as Lucius, the son of Maximus, in Gladiator II, arguing it limits his ability to explore complex character dynamics.
Despite the backlash, those who support Mescal’s casting point to his commitment to a physically demanding role. Although Gladiator II may not allow him to delve into the intricacies he typically showcases, Mescal’s performance as Lucius reflects his impressive versatility. He demonstrates surprising ferocity and determination, although his limited character development may lead to perceptions of repetitiveness, suggesting that this critique is more a reflection of the character than of Mescal’s capabilities as an actor.
2 Pedro Pascal
Evaluate Pedro Pascal’s Role as General Acacius
Pedro Pascal has emerged as a leading figure in film and television, recognized for his outstanding performances in Game of Thrones, The Mandalorian, and The Last of Us. In Gladiator II, Pascal’s character, General Acadius, is one of the most complex and nuanced roles, showcasing his evolution from enemy to ally of Lucius. Acadius is depicted as a reluctant servant to Rome, navigating the absurd demands of the two Emperor brothers while remaining loyal to his beliefs.
Pascal’s portrayal of Acadius is rich with emotional depth and wisdom, which adds a compelling layer to the character. He skillfully balances the internal conflict of serving an Empire he may oppose while caring for Lucilla and Lucius. His ability to convey honor and sacrifice resonates throughout the film, making Acadius a standout character. Through Pascal’s performance, the audience witnesses a General who is not only dedicated but also capable of deep emotional connections, enhancing the overall narrative of Gladiator II.
1 Denzel Washington
Experience Denzel Washington’s Commanding Performance as Macrinus
Denzel Washington captivates audiences in Gladiator II, delivering a performance that elevates his character, Macrinus, to new heights. With an Oscar-winning background, Washington has the potential to earn his third Academy Award for this role. His portrayal of the manipulative and strategic Macrinus, who initially shares a common vision with Lucius to dismantle and rebuild Rome, is nothing short of remarkable. Washington’s commanding presence is palpable in every scene, showcasing his ability to dominate the screen.
Achieving a third Oscar would place Washington among the ranks of legendary actors such as Jack Nicholson and Meryl Streep. His performance as the cunning Macrinus, who navigates complex alliances and motivations, is a testament to his skill. Washington’s ability to convey depth and intensity is unmatched, making him the standout performer in Gladiator II, even amidst a strong ensemble cast.