Stephen King‘s first novel, Carrie, catapulted him to literary fame and for good reason. This gripping narrative artfully weaves together elements of supernatural horror with the harsh realities of bullying and isolation. The story’s compelling premise makes it an excellent candidate for cinematic adaptation. Over the years, there have been four distinct film adaptations, yet only one of these truly stands out as a masterpiece. The others, unfortunately, range from merely forgettable to outright disappointing, failing to capture the essence of King’s original vision.

Considering this backdrop, we present a ranked list of these films, each evaluated based on their unique interpretations, from the loosely connected 1999 sequel to the contemporary retelling featuring Chloë Grace Moretz. Despite the efforts of these adaptations, none come close to the brilliance of Brian De Palma‘s iconic 1976 version, which remains a vital film in the horror genre, while the others feel largely inconsequential.

4 ‘The Rage: Carrie 2’ (1999)

Discover the Directorial Vision of Katt Shea

“I always wanted to be one of the shiny, happy people.” Regrettably, this film stands as the weakest entry among the Carrie adaptations. Initially conceived as an independent horror movie, it was later reworked into a loose sequel to the acclaimed 1976 film. In this installment, Emily Bergl stars as Rachel Lang, a high school student who faces alienation and bullying from her peers, all while grappling with her own traumatic past. As the plot unfolds, she discovers that she possesses telekinetic powers reminiscent of Carrie White’s.

While the film attempts to rejuvenate the Carrie narrative for a late ’90s audience, The Rage: Carrie 2 fails to deliver the emotional depth and complexity that characterized the original story. Although Bergl’s performance is commendable, the film often veers between dull and ludicrous. Director Katt Shea lacks the visual artistry of De Palma, resulting in a film that feels flat and uninspired compared to the original’s vivid storytelling.

Watch on Tubi

3 ‘Carrie’ (2002)

Explore the Adaptation Directed by David Carson

“Go to your closet and pray.” The 2002 television adaptation of Carrie stars Angela Bettis in the titular role and takes significant liberties with the source material. The narrative is structured with flashbacks, keeping viewers in suspense about Carrie’s ultimate fate for an extended period, perhaps in an attempt to mirror the epistolary style found in King’s original novel.

Despite this innovative approach, the overall film suffers due to a lackluster script, extended runtime, and subpar special effects that even the director conceded were “cheap.” The portrayal of bullying has faced criticism for being unrealistic and outdated, while the horror elements are disappointingly tepid, failing to create the suspenseful atmosphere that would engage audiences. Bettis’s performance, however, has garnered praise, showcasing her ability to elevate a project with limited resources.

Rent on AppleTV

2 ‘Carrie’ (2013)

Unpack the 2013 Remake Directed by Kimberly Peirce

“If I concentrate hard enough, I can make things move.” The 2013 remake places the classic tale within the context of modern technology, introducing elements like viral videos to depict bullying in today’s world. Chloë Grace Moretz takes on the role of Carrie, with Julianne Moore portraying her fanatically religious mother, Margaret. Despite the film’s star-studded cast, the end result is a lackluster rendition that feels unnecessary.

The characters lack depth, becoming mere shadows of the original portrayals, making it challenging for audiences to connect with them in a contemporary setting. Moretz’s interpretation of Carrie fails to convincingly convey the character’s oddness and emotional turmoil. Under the direction of Kimberly Peirce, the film opts for a safe retelling rather than a bold reimagining, ultimately resulting in a version of Carrie that squanders its potential and leaves viewers feeling underwhelmed.

Watch on Prime

1 ‘Carrie’ (1976)

Experience the Timeless Classic Directed by Brian De Palma

“They’re all gonna laugh at you!” Standing out as the pinnacle of all Carrie adaptations, Brian De Palma’s 1976 film is often hailed as one of the greatest horror movies of the 1970s. Starring Sissy Spacek in the lead role, alongside the outstanding Piper Laurie as her mother, both actresses earned Oscar nominations for their exceptional performances. Their authentic portrayals skillfully balance the film’s supernatural elements with the very real horrors of adolescent cruelty, enhancing the overall sense of dread throughout the narrative.

De Palma masterfully transforms King’s story into a visually striking exploration of adolescence, bullying, and religious fanaticism. His unique directorial style is evident through techniques such as effective suspense-building and innovative split-screen sequences, culminating in a climactic finale marked by an unforgettable scene filled with blood and chaos. This film is not just a classic; it casts a long shadow over the horror genre, setting a high bar that future adaptations will likely struggle to reach.

Carrie

Carrie is a horror film directed by Brian De Palma, based on Stephen King’s novel. It stars Sissy Spacek as Carrie White, a shy high school student who discovers her telekinetic abilities. Tormented by her peers and controlled by her fanatically religious mother, played by Piper Laurie, the film follows Carrie’s emotional and psychological struggles leading to a dramatic climax. Carrie solidified its place in the horror genre for its powerful performances and chilling atmosphere.

Watch on Prime

NEXT: 10 Great Movies Recommended by Jude Law