The frontman of Hatebreed and renowned podcast host, Jamey Jasta, recently revisited the significant backlash he faced after challenging As I Lay Dying‘s Tim Lambesis during an interview in April. This contentious discussion centered around Lambesis’ controversial musical comeback following his prison sentence for attempting to hire a hitman to kill his ex-wife, which raised ethical questions about accountability in the music industry.

In his latest appearance on the LOS Podcast (embedded below), Jasta addressed this topic while the hosts initially approached it with a dark sense of humor. However, Jasta redirected the conversation toward a more serious tone, sharing insights into the intense reactions he received from fans after the interview with Lambesis was aired.

Jamey Jasta Reflects on Fan Backlash After Interviewing Tim Lambesis

Reflecting on his previous interview with Lambesis, Jasta noted, “We did the podcast [with Tim] and people criticized me for being too harsh and my questions being inappropriate. I thought, ‘The guy survived prison… what’s a few questions over Zoom?’” This statement highlights his perspective on the responsibility of artists to address their past actions openly.

During the same podcast episode, Jasta explained that he imposed no restrictions on the interview, expressing gratitude that Lambesis agreed to participate without limits on the questioning. He acknowledged, however, that Lambesis preferred not to revisit topics that had already been extensively covered in the media, indicating a level of sensitivity surrounding his past.

As the conversation developed on the LOS Podcast, Jasta elaborated, “Fans often become deeply attached to their favorite bands, wanting to support them regardless of their past actions. Many adopt the mindset of ‘separating the art from the artist.’ I asked direct questions, such as, ‘Do you still have a restraining order against your ex-wife and children?’ There were crucial issues he couldn’t address, as I felt it was vital to know, especially if we were to tour together or share the stage,” he emphasized.

Jasta further pointed out, “If the hitman Lambesis attempted to hire hadn’t been an undercover cop, she would be dead. Some individuals were willing to vouch for him, and one of them, Ken [Susi], expressed to me later that he regretted supporting Lambesis.” This illustrates the complexity of loyalty and ethics within the music community.

The Hatebreed frontman candidly remarked, “It’s a tough situation for diehard fans of Lambesis. I asked, ‘Is your ex-wife still in witness protection?’ and he was unable to answer. During the interview, he became emotional, which led many to criticize me, saying things like, ‘How could Jasta be so insensitive?’” This highlights the emotional weight of the issues discussed and the polarized opinions among listeners.

He recalled, “I was among the few who publicly criticized Lambesis, stating my views on multiple occasions. Not many others did so. You could probably find it online; I was one of the only people who said, ‘No, forget this guy! What he did is unacceptable. He should really be canceled.’ Within one day, I received about 400 tweets attacking me, asking, ‘Did you ever want to kill your wife?!’ I had to clarify, ‘No, that’s not what I meant…’”

On the Jasta Show episode featuring Lambesis, Jasta made it clear that he has never harbored thoughts of harming his wife or anyone close to him, emphasizing his commitment to healthy relationships.

Jamey Jasta Shares Insights on the LOS Podcast

Addressing the Controversial Backlash From Tim Lambesis Interview

In April 2024, Jasta shared a comprehensive podcast episode with Lambesis, where he expressed his disappointment over the fan mail he had received in response to his public comments about Lambesis. He articulated, “Reviewing the feedback was disheartening. It felt like many fans sided with you based on my previous statements.” This reaction compelled him to reassess how he interacts with fans and consider the implications of their sentiments.

“It was disappointing for me. It made me realize that a lot of individuals harbor thoughts of harming their partners or engaging in terrible actions,” Jasta remarked. “I don’t want to expose anyone, but I questioned if these are the kinds of fans I want to cultivate. I strive to respond courteously, but some directed their anger at me, believing I was being unforgiving or closed-minded.” This insight reflects the challenges artists face in navigating fan relationships while upholding their values.

He continued, “I had to wrestle with this response because the volume of feedback was significant. Coming from a band whose fan mail often originates from prison, I genuinely wanted those who reached out to me to find forgiveness and rebuild their lives.” This sentiment emphasizes Jasta’s commitment to personal growth and redemption.

As Jasta discussed his evolving perspective based on the reactions he received, he added, “Now that some time has passed, and after seeing each other multiple times since your release, I feel more comfortable. However, the question remains: are you truly on the right path?” This question encapsulates the ongoing journey of understanding and accountability.

Tim Lambesis Displays Vulnerability During Previous Jasta Show Podcast

During the same April 2024 podcast, Lambesis displayed vulnerability and became emotional during the discussion. The pivotal moment occurred when Jasta inquired about Lambesis’ remarriage and aspirations for starting a new family. Lambesis took a moment to collect himself before responding, “I don’t believe I’ve healed enough to delve into that topic right now.” His honesty underscores the complexities of healing from past traumas.

After gathering his thoughts and wiping away tears, Lambesis shared, “We often have a tendency to categorize individuals as entirely good or entirely bad, which is why we enjoy superhero narratives. Life is inherently complicated. I’m not asserting that I’m a great person, but I recognize that there is goodness within me, alongside the recognition of my past wrongdoings.” This statement reflects a nuanced understanding of morality and personal growth.

“There aren’t many clear-cut answers that allow people to walk away with a definitive perspective. If there were a straightforward way to evaluate me, we could simply consult an expert to clarify how to perceive Tim Lambesis,” he concluded, emphasizing the challenge of understanding human complexity.

Tim Lambesis Discusses His Journey on The Jasta Show Podcast in April 2024

As I Lay Dying’s Turbulent Changes and Tim Lambesis’ Challenges in 2024

The focus shifted back to Tim Lambesis and As I Lay Dying as events unfolded in the fall of 2024.

Between late October and early November, several members of Lambesis’ bands began to part ways with their positions, starting with bassist Ryan Neff, followed by Ken Susi, Nick Pierce, and ultimately the longest-serving member, Phil Sgrosso. This mass departure raised questions about the band’s future dynamics and stability.

Susi expressed that his “personal morals” faced significant challenges in reaching his decision to leave the group. Pierce mentioned the necessity to distance himself to maintain his personal health and integrity, while Sgrosso pointed out “concerning patterns of behavior” within the group, stating that it no longer provided a healthy or safe environment for its members.

Additionally, drummer Brandon Short from Lambesis’ other project, Austrian Death Machine, also exited, citing his departure as being “for the sake of my mental well-being and personal beliefs.” This trend of departures raises serious concerns regarding the internal dynamics and future viability of the bands involved.

READ MORE: Tim Lambesis Responds After Videos of Disturbing Exchanges With His Ex-Wife Surface

In his first statement following the exits of band members, Lambesis acknowledged “an unhealthy environment” within As I Lay Dying, while also expressing his intention to continue the band with a new lineup. This declaration reflects his commitment to moving forward despite the challenges.

However, just ahead of Thanksgiving, shocking videos surfaced online, revealing disturbing exchanges with Lambesis’ ex-wife, Dany. Shortly thereafter, Lambesis announced that he had filed a restraining order against her, noting that she was now “formerly Lambesis.” He also claimed that a domestic violence investigation had been initiated, further complicating his current situation.