Gladiator II: Oliver Stone Critiques Ridley Scott’s Film
Oliver Stone has openly expressed his critical perspective on Ridley Scott’s highly anticipated sequel, Gladiator II. He referred to the film as “empty calories,” suggesting that it lacks the substance and depth that characterized the original masterpiece. His remarks stem from a broader curiosity about how directors perceive each other’s works, highlighting the competitive yet respectful nature of the film industry.
During a recent episode of the PBD Podcast, Stone shared his thoughts about the sequel, stating, “It’s certainly watchable. It’s good, well made, and continues the usual tight narrative style characteristic of Ridley Scott’s films. However, I found myself not caring about the characters; I wasn’t emotionally invested in their journey.” His critique further emphasized the stark contrast to the first film, which he deemed a classic. Stone lamented that the sequel felt more like a commercial product rather than an artistic endeavor, lacking the emotional depth that resonated with audiences in the original.
Despite Stone’s lukewarm reception of Gladiator II, he did express admiration for another film released this year: Francis Ford Coppola’s Megalopolis. He described it as “visually stunning,” noting that each scene is a breathtaking experience that surpasses even Coppola’s renowned works like Apocalypse Now and the unique One from the Heart. Stone acknowledged that while the narrative may be complex and has faced criticism, he feels compelled to see the film again. He appreciates Coppola’s sincere exploration of a future society, one that strives for humanitarian values that seem beyond our current understanding.
The official synopsis for Gladiator II describes the continuation of the epic saga: “From legendary director Ridley Scott, Gladiator II continues the gripping tale of power, intrigue, and vengeance set in Ancient Rome.” The narrative follows young Lucius, played by Paul Mescal, who after witnessing the tragic death of the revered hero Maximus, must confront the tyrannical emperors ruling Rome. As he is thrust into the Colosseum’s brutal arena, Lucius grapples with his past while seeking the strength and honor needed to restore glory to Rome and its people.
In a recent review, our own Chris Bumbray acknowledged that while Gladiator II may not achieve the same iconic status as its predecessor, “it remains a highly entertaining and faithful sequel that is rich in action and spectacle.” He pointed out that it has been a considerable time since a lavish, action-packed historical drama has been crafted on such a grand scale. Even as Ridley Scott advances in age, he continues to demonstrate an energetic and kinetic directorial style that captivates audiences. You can read the full review by Chris Bumbray for further insights.
