Captain America: Brave New World marks a significant turning point in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, introducing Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) as the new Captain America, stepping into a role previously held by Steve Rogers (Chris Evans). Although audiences first witnessed Sam wield the iconic Vibranium shield in the 2021 miniseries The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, this film expands on his journey. The miniseries delves into the complexities of Sam’s acceptance of the Captain America mantle amidst the backdrop of institutional racism. Unfortunately, the series faced criticism influenced by real-world biases, yet those who approach it with an open mind will uncover one of the MCU?s most profound narratives, enriched by the dynamic chemistry between Mackie and co-star Sebastian Stan, who portrays James ?Bucky? Barnes, the Winter Soldier.
Discover How ‘The Falcon and the Winter Soldier’ Explores the Challenges of Becoming Captain America
Taking place approximately six months after the climactic events of Avengers: Endgame, <em>The Falcon and the Winter Soldier</em> opens with Sam Wilson’s refusal to accept the Captain America mantle. In a symbolic act, he returns the shield to the Smithsonian, igniting frustration in Bucky Barnes. Their partnership is tested when the U.S. government appoints John Walker (Wyatt Russell), a soldier lacking genuine ties to Steve Rogers’ legacy, as the new Captain America. As Sam and Bucky navigate their tumultuous relationship, which blends both dramatic and comedic elements, they also investigate the Flag Smashers?an activist group advocating for a world without borders, whose escalating methods raise concerns of terrorism, particularly as many members possess superhuman abilities akin to those of Steve.
Sam’s journey leads him to confront the troubling history of America?s super soldier initiatives, particularly through his encounter with Isaiah Bradley (Carl Lumbly), a character whose experiences shed light on the racial injustices intertwined with the superhero narrative. This revelation makes Sam’s eventual decision to reclaim the Captain America mantle, following Walker’s dishonorable discharge, all the more poignant and satisfying. Meanwhile, Bucky grapples with his traumatic past as a brainwashed assassin, providing a relatable exploration of the mental health struggles faced by many veterans. The series highlights the evolution of Sam and Bucky’s friendship, showcasing a bond that is both platonic and deeply affectionate?an increasingly rare depiction of male friendships in mainstream media, which Mackie proudly champions.
Unpacking the Controversial Criticism Faced by ‘The Falcon and the Winter Soldier’
While The Falcon and the Winter Soldier has its share of legitimate criticisms, particularly concerning the portrayals of the Flag Smasher leader Karli Morgenthau (Erin Kellyman) and former agent Sharon Carter (Emily VanCamp), these characters still contribute significantly to the overarching narrative. Karli’s character, while not as nuanced as intended, embodies the struggle of youth feeling compelled to resort to violence for change, resonating with Sam’s fight against political corruption. Conversely, Sharon’s transformation into a morally ambiguous character has disappointed many fans, but VanCamp’s portrayal of her darker side adds complexity to the story.
However, certain criticisms of the series appear to be less about the content and more about underlying biases, particularly regarding its emphasis on diverse characters and socially relevant themes. For instance, during the finale, Sam’s passionate address to a corrupt official (Alphie Hyorth) urging them to “do better” for marginalized communities faced undue scrutiny. Critics pointed out the lack of concrete solutions in his speech, highlighting a double standard?Steve Rogers often made similar calls to action without facing similar backlash. This discrepancy reveals an unsettling trend of dismissing socially conscious narratives when presented through a different lens.
Related
Can ?Captain America: Brave New World? Continue the Box Office Success of ?Deadpool & Wolverine??
Opinions on the MCU are diverse and evolving, especially following the impressive performance of Deadpool & Wolverine, which grossed over $1.3 billion globally. In the wake of Avengers: Endgame, Marvel has seen other commercial successes, like Spider-Man: No Way Home and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, both featuring beloved characters. With Captain America: Brave New World set to premiere soon, will it align more with the significant successes of Phases 4 and 5, or will it struggle to match the box office achievements of previous Captain America films? Notably, The Winter Soldier earned $714 million globally, raising questions about whether Brave New World can achieve comparable results.
Additionally, the expectations surrounding Sam and Steve?s characters seem to misunderstand their roles within the narrative framework. Both heroes recognize the profound significance of the Captain America identity, yet neither Sam nor Steve seeks to become politicians. Their primary objective is to safeguard public safety; although they sometimes adopt bold measures, such as Sam advocating for an end to the systemic issues that birthed the Flag Smashers, they ultimately leave policymaking to elected officials. Thus, expecting a fictional superhero like Sam to solve intricate societal problems single-handedly is not only unrealistic but also misrepresents the essence of their journey.
Moreover, the timing of the show’s release likely impacted its reception. Premiering shortly after the groundbreaking WandaVision, which presented a unique perspective on superhero storytelling, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier may have faced unfair comparisons. It is hoped that future audiences can differentiate between valid criticisms and those rooted in bias, recognizing the series’ strengths, including its compelling writing on significant themes, high production quality, and standout performances from actors such as Russell, Lumbly, Daniel Brühl, Florence Kasumba, and particularly the leading duo, Mackie and Stan, who have cemented their characters as two of Marvel?s best, both individually and in partnership.
The Falcon and the Winter Soldier is available for streaming on Disney+ in the U.S.
