More than two decades after its initial release, <em>Catwoman</em> has surprisingly outperformed a number of superhero films at the box office, defying expectations. As a pivotal character within the DC universe, especially in relation to Batman, Catwoman is recognized even by those who are not avid comic book fans, akin to iconic figures like The Joker or Robin. However, mere popularity within the Batman franchise does not guarantee cinematic success, a notion reinforced by the recent box office performance of Joker: Folie à Deux, which faced its own challenges despite its strong character association.

Long before the controversial sequel to Joker, DC had already illustrated the disparity between character popularity and box office success through the dismal financial and critical reception of Catwoman. For several years, this film has been viewed as one of the most poorly received superhero adaptations. However, as we reassess its financial performance in light of the superhero genre’s evolution, Catwoman‘s box office rankings appear more favorable now that time has passed, especially when juxtaposed with the disappointing performances of several recent superhero films.

Catwoman: Analyzing Its Reputation as One of the Worst Superhero Movies and Its Box Office Performance

From a conceptual standpoint, a Catwoman film presents an intriguing opportunity. Delving into the origin story of a central character in Batman’s narrative has proven to be immensely profitable when executed effectively, as evidenced by the success of 2019’s Joker. The dual nature of Selina Kyle—as both a villain and a hero—opens numerous storytelling avenues that remain faithful to the established lore. Unfortunately, the 2004 film was met with near-universal criticism, a sentiment that persists, reflected in a dismal Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer score of just 8% and a Popcornmeter score of 18%, which underscores its negative reputation.

While a lackluster critical response does not invariably hinder a superhero film’s ability to achieve significant box office earnings, it certainly diminishes the likelihood of such success. This principle was clearly applicable to Catwoman. The film’s global box office total stands at a mere $82 million (according to The Numbers), which pales in comparison to its estimated production budget of around $100 million. This financial shortfall becomes even more glaring when placed alongside the box office performance of other superhero films released during the same era.

For context, 2004’s animated feature Shrek 2 amassed an astounding $933 million worldwide, while the superhero film Spider-Man 2 raked in $795 million during the same year. These figures starkly contrast with Catwoman‘s modest takings, particularly when even the less celebrated 2003 adaptation of Daredevil managed to exceed Catwoman with a worldwide box office of $182 million.

Reflecting on 2025: Catwoman’s Box Office Triumphs Over Other Superhero Movies

While Catwoman‘s box office figures have not changed in the 21 years since its premiere, its ranking within the superhero film landscape has shifted significantly. As many contemporary superhero movies have underperformed financially, Catwoman‘s standing among superhero films and their respective box office returns appears more favorable today, despite its original lack of commercial success.

In the years immediately following Catwoman‘s release, several superhero films reported worldwide box office earnings lower than those of Catwoman. The closest contender to its financial performance is 2005’s Elektra, which garnered approximately $56 million, followed by The Punisher and Punisher: War Zone, which reported earnings of $54 million and $10 million, respectively.

In more recent years, additional films have also fallen short of Catwoman‘s $82 million total, including 2020’s The New Mutants, which managed only $47 million despite being part of the established Fox X-Men franchise, and Kraven The Hunter, which concluded its run at $60 million, signaling a downturn for Sony’s Spider-Man Universe. Although many films continue to achieve higher box office results, this trend elevates Catwoman‘s financial standing, especially considering that inflation could potentially make surpassing its earnings easier for subsequent releases.

Exploring the Factors Behind Catwoman’s Superior Box Office Performance Compared to Other Superhero Films

The criticisms leveled against Catwoman‘s narrative, character development, and overall execution have been thoroughly analyzed over the years, revealing a significant impact on the film’s financial performance. Notably, Catwoman premiered during a period when the superhero genre was still establishing its footing within the film industry, which contributed to a mixed record of financial success among various releases. Interestingly, elements such as timing and audience reception also shed light on why certain films performed worse at the box office.

Films like Elektra and the two Punisher adaptations faced similar criticisms as Catwoman, but arguably suffered more due to their association with less recognizable characters compared to the well-known figure of Catwoman, who is deeply intertwined with Batman’s mythology. Moreover, all three films were released around the same time, preventing them from capitalizing on the genre’s growing popularity, which later Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) films successfully leveraged.

More recently, both The New Mutants and Kraven The Last Hunter were perceived as the final installments of their respective cinematic universes—though the Fox universe has experienced a resurgence with Deadpool & Wolverine. These films struggled to connect with audiences, lacking the necessary ties to their franchises’ overarching narratives to generate interest. Additionally, the release of The New Mutants during the COVID-19 pandemic, when theaters were either closed or sparsely attended, severely hindered its box office potential, while the negative reputation of the Sony Spider-Man Universe also adversely impacted Kraven‘s success.

It is important to note that the rise of streaming services since Catwoman‘s release has altered viewing habits, leading audiences intrigued by a film’s poor reviews to opt for streaming releases instead of theatrical viewings. The typically short window between theatrical and streaming availability for underperforming films means that those interested in films like Catwoman may choose to wait for streaming options. The success of films such as Kraven The Hunter on platforms like Netflix indicates a sustained interest that might have translated into better box office performance if the film had been more engaging, thereby providing additional context for its comparison to Catwoman.

Upcoming Releases in the DC Universe