MASH season 6 showcased an intriguing episode in which Hawkeye has minimal presence, suggesting the sitcom could thrive even without the gregarious surgeon in the spotlight. MASH spanned 11 seasons, initially intended as an ensemble show, but Alan Alda quickly took center stage. By season 3, Alda’s portrayal of Hawkeye became the primary focus, as he expertly balanced moments of humor and deep emotional resonance. Alda’s influence extended beyond acting; he also contributed significantly to the series by writing and directing numerous episodes, shaping its overall direction and tone.
Hawkeye is undoubtedly a beloved character and the heart of the series. However, the reliance on the fast-talking surgeon became increasingly evident over time. Notably, Hawkeye is the sole character to appear in every episode of MASH, and even in moments when he isn’t the focal point, he often remains a dominant presence. It would have been fascinating to experience a full episode of MASH without Hawkeye, with the closest instance being season 6’s “Temporary Duty.”
Related
Discover Why MASH Required Two Different Pilot Episodes to Find Its Groove
The classic sitcom MASH took time to find its footing in the ratings, necessitating the creation of a second pilot episode for its second season.
Exploring How MASH’s “Temporary Duty” Minimizes Alan Alda’s Iconic Hawkeye Character
Analyzing Hawkeye’s Limited Presence in Season 6’s Unique Episode
The episode “Temporary Duty” from MASH season 6 begins with Hawkeye being reassigned to another unit for a week, prompting the 4077th to welcome a new surgeon and nurse. This shift results in Hawkeye’s total absence outside of the opening and closing sequences of “Temporary Duty.” The unique dynamic of the episode emerges as Alda’s character is not present to deliver his iconic dry humor or charming remarks. Instead, the narrative pivots around the remainder of the unit grappling with the frustrating replacement and Margaret (Loretta Swit) rekindling a friendship with an old acquaintance.
Captain Roy Dupree, portrayed by George Lindsey, steps in for Hawkeye at the camp, but he serves as the episode’s primary drawback. Tasked with being an irritating figure, Dupree mostly annoys B.J. (Mike Farrell) and Winchester (David Ogden Stiers) without bringing the expected humor. Nonetheless, viewers should not miss this episode, as it provides a rare glimpse into a version of MASH without its central character, Hawkeye.
“Temporary Duty” Highlights the Talents of MASH’s Supporting Cast
Examining Margaret’s Role as the Emotional Core of This MASH Episode
With Hawkeye absent, the focus shifts to B.J., Margaret, and Winchester in “Temporary Duty.” While the dynamic between Charles and B.J. can be entertaining, it is somewhat overshadowed by their interactions with Dupree. The episode’s highlight comes from Margaret reuniting with the fun-loving nurse Lorraine (Marcia Rodd), who is taken aback by how much more serious her former friend has become. Margaret confides that the responsibilities of war have forced her into a more distant role, leaving her feeling isolated despite her desire for connection.
Margaret’s storyline is the most compelling of the episode, culminating in a touching moment where she invites B.J. and Charles for coffee, showcasing her personal growth…
Among the characters in MASH, Margaret undergoes the most significant transformation throughout the series, evolving from a one-dimensional antagonist to a multi-faceted individual. “Temporary Duty” serves as a pivotal moment for her character, as she starts to understand the importance of maintaining connections with others. Despite being the B story, Margaret’s arc stands out, and the closing scene where she extends an invitation to B.J. and Charles for coffee marks a notable step in her character development.
“Temporary Duty” Demonstrates MASH’s Ability to Succeed Without Relying Heavily on Hawkeye
Reflecting on the Potential for More Episodes Without Hawkeye
“Temporary Duty” presents a mixed bag, functioning more effectively as a drama than a traditional comedy. Nonetheless, this episode illustrates that MASH’s ensemble cast was robust enough to thrive without Hawkeye’s constant presence. It’s notable that the episode refrains from showcasing cutaways to Hawkeye at the other camp, likely because Alda preferred a lighter workload for this particular episode.
This episode is as close as MASH came to attempting a Hawkeye-free narrative, and it is regrettable that it did not explore this concept further. While Alda’s contributions are invaluable, the enduring appeal of the show hinged upon its collective cast. The humor and humanity they brought to the series made it captivating and essential viewing, and the absence of Hawkeye in “Temporary Duty” illustrates that the show could indeed operate effectively without him.
MASH frequently experimented with its formula over the years, including unique offerings like “The Interview” and “Dreams.” A Hawkeye-free episode seems like a natural extension of this experimental spirit, yet perhaps the creators feared that audiences would disengage if Alda was missing entirely, which led to the missed opportunity for such a bold narrative choice. Some might argue that AfterMASH demonstrated that the series needed Alda to succeed, but the failed spinoff primarily highlighted that the entire ensemble was essential for the show’s success.
