The talented Milo Ventimiglia, renowned for his role in the hit series This Is Us, has officially joined the cast of the highly anticipated film I Can Only Imagine 2. This movie serves as a sequel to the beloved 2018 biographical drama of the same title. In this new installment, the Emmy-nominated actor will bring to life the character of singer/songwriter Tim Timmons, further enriching the narrative of faith and resilience that captivated audiences in the original.

Meet the Creative Team and Cast Behind I Can Only Imagine 2

The sequel, I Can Only Imagine 2, is being brought to life by the talented directing duo of Brent McCorkle and Andrew Erwin, who are also responsible for the film’s screenplay. Joining Ventimiglia in this inspiring journey are returning cast members, including the acclaimed John Michael Finley, reprising his role as Bart Millard, alongside Dennis Quaid as Arthur, and Trace Adkins as Scott Brickell, the manager of MercyMe. This production, enriched by the involvement of producers such as Millard, Erwin, Kevin Downes, Cindy Bond, Daryl Lefever, and Joshua Walsh, is a collaboration between Lionsgate and Kingdom Story Company, ensuring a high-quality cinematic experience.

In a heartfelt statement, producer Kevin Downes expressed, “The original I Can Only Imagine film resonated deeply with audiences upon its release and continues to inspire hope and positivity for millions worldwide. The film’s success led to the establishment of Kingdom Story Company, where we are dedicated to sharing stories that evoke a ‘rush of hope.’ We are incredibly excited to revisit this world and delve deeper into Bart’s remarkable journey in our company’s first-ever sequel. Co-directors Andrew Erwin and Brent McCorkle, along with Bart Millard, have created an emotionally compelling and inspiring narrative that will resonate with both loyal fans of the first film and newcomers alike.”

The original 2018 film centered around the inspiring life of Bart Millard, the lead singer of MercyMe. It achieved significant commercial success, grossing an impressive $86 million at the global box office against a modest budget of only $7 million. The cast also featured notable actors such as Madeline Carroll, Gianna Simone, Priscilla Shirer, Tanya Clarke, and the late Cloris Leachman, contributing to the film’s rich storytelling and emotional impact.