With the release of Moana 2 being met with mixed reviews, the anticipation surrounding the upcoming live-action remake of Moana has diminished somewhat. After finally watching Moana 2 on Disney+, I found that the critiques regarding its disjointed narrative are valid. Transforming the original streaming series into a sequel film resulted in a storyline that lacked cohesion. Additionally, the musical numbers in Moana 2 fail to capture the magic of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s unforgettable compositions from the original. While Moana was a tightly crafted masterpiece, Moana 2 feels more akin to the lesser quality of direct-to-video Disney sequels.

Interestingly, my disappointment with Moana 2 has sparked a newfound optimism for the live-action adaptation of Moana, scheduled for release on July 10, 2026. This remake aims to retell the beloved original tale, enhancing the emotional depth and visual spectacle of the story through a live-action format that vividly portrays the challenges of navigating open waters. Newcomer Catherine Lagaʻaia will portray Moana, while Dwayne Johnson is set to return as the charismatic demigod Maui. Initially, I approached the idea of a live-action remake with skepticism, but the lackluster reception of Moana 2 has made me more open to the concept.

The Pressure on Moana’s Live-Action Remake Has Eased Following Moana 2’s Reception

Understanding the Hit-and-Miss Nature of the Moana Franchise

The Moana franchise has officially entered a phase of unpredictability following the release of its recent sequel. Initially, the live-action adaptation seemed poised to uphold the legacy of a flawless animated classic. However, the release of a mediocre sequel has already impacted that legacy, proving that not every continuation will meet high expectations. While Moana 2 isn’t entirely without merit—featuring engaging moments and emotional depth—it simply does not measure up to the brilliance of the original film. Consequently, the live-action remake now faces less pressure to uphold a reputation that has already been challenged.

With the Moana live-action remake on the horizon, expectations were already low due to the recent release of the original animated film and Disney’s track record with live-action versions. Now, it becomes evident that the animated side of the franchise isn’t as untouchable as previously thought; it too has experienced moments of mediocrity. Even if the live-action adaptation doesn’t resonate as strongly with audiences, its potential failure will likely feel less impactful, as the threshold for disappointment has already been established. In fact, the mixed reviews of Moana 2 may liberate the live-action project from the burden of high expectations.

Anticipating the Magic of New Lin-Manuel Miranda Songs in Moana’s Live-Action Remake

The Impact of a New Hit Song from Lin-Manuel Miranda

After missing out on Moana 2 due to his other commitments with Mufasa: The Lion King, Lin-Manuel Miranda is returning to create new songs for the live-action adaptation of Moana. The likelihood of Miranda composing new music for the remake is high, as it’s improbable that Disney would invite him back solely for remixes of previous tracks. This fresh musical input could provide the remake with the unique flair it needs to distinguish itself from its animated predecessor.

A new composition from the talented creator behind hits like “You’re Welcome” and “How Far I’ll Go” would significantly enhance the live-action Moana remake, providing it an edge over the sequel. Many fans were left underwhelmed by Moana 2 due to its forgettable musical numbers, a clear result of Miranda’s absence from the soundtrack. If the remake is able to deliver a new hit from Miranda, it could greatly elevate its appeal and success.

The Moana Live-Action Remake Will Showcase More of Maui’s Charisma

Maui’s Underwhelming Role in Moana 2

Maui’s character in Moana 2 fell short of expectations, with his significant presence only becoming apparent halfway through the film. Given his popularity from the original movie and the established friendship with Moana, it would have made narrative sense for him to have a more prominent role throughout the sequel. However, Moana 2 was not structured like a conventional sequel, as it was originally conceived as a TV series. It’s also worth noting that it’s unlikely that Dwayne Johnson, one of Hollywood’s biggest stars, would participate in a television format.

During the development of the original streaming series, Maui’s character may have been reserved for later episodes, which limited his role in the resulting movie. Fortunately, fans can expect a more substantial presence from Maui in the live-action adaptation of Moana. Dwayne Johnson is set to reprise his role, and Disney is likely eager to capitalize on his star power. Additionally, since the live-action remake closely follows the plot of the first film, which prominently featured Maui, this adaptation could fulfill the desires of fans hoping for more of their favorite character, especially after his underwhelming role in Moana 2.

Source link