When audiences develop a deep connection with a film, the desire to rewatch it often emerges. The rewatch value of a movie stands as a pivotal element in the realms of fandom culture and the creation of cult followings, establishing its significance in the film’s enduring legacy. However, rewatchability is not the sole measure of a film’s greatness. Over the years, numerous cinematic masterpieces have captured the hearts of viewers, even if the thought of experiencing them again feels overwhelming.
Surprisingly, even the most intense horror films, the most poignant dramas, the longest experimental pieces, and the harshest war narratives can possess some degree of rewatchability. Yet, it takes an extraordinary film, one that is either profoundly impactful or undeniably disturbing, to cultivate a fanbase that prefers to treasure just the singular experience of the initial viewing. These films are remarkable in their storytelling but often too harrowing to revisit repeatedly, and this list will explore those films ranked from the least challenging to the most daunting to rewatch.
10
‘Manchester by the Sea’ (2016)
Directed by Kenneth Lonergan
Known primarily for his exceptional work as a screenwriter and playwright, Kenneth Lonergan has also directed some remarkable films, with Manchester by the Sea standing out as his magnum opus. This film is a heartbreaking exploration of grief, guilt, and depression, anchored by an emotionally charged performance from Casey Affleck, who won an Oscar for his role. It serves as a powerful testament to the depths of human sorrow that cinema can convey.
Manchester by the Sea is widely regarded as one of the saddest films ever created, and it achieves this without resorting to melodrama. Unlike many films that attempt to evoke sadness through overtly cruel or artificial means, this narrative resonates deeply due to its authenticity and sincerity. The masterful portrayals by Affleck and Michelle Williams might entice some viewers to experience their performances again, yet the emotional weight of the story makes it a daunting endeavor.
9
‘Brokeback Mountain’ (2005)
Directed by Ang Lee
As one of the most significant queer films in cinema history, Brokeback Mountain is celebrated for its profound narrative about love that transcends societal boundaries. This film tells a traditional tale of doomed love, yet does so in a uniquely poignant manner. With breathtaking visuals, an epic tone, and groundbreaking performances by Jake Gyllenhaal and the late Heath Ledger, Brokeback Mountain stands as a hallmark of romantic drama in the 21st century.
While many romantic films boast high rewatch value, captivating audiences with their love stories, even those centered on tragic romance, such as La La Land and Casablanca, possess the elements that make heartbreak worth revisiting. Although Brokeback Mountain includes these captivating aspects, the emotional toll required to journey through its narrative is steep. While it is adored by romance enthusiasts, very few are willing to brave a second viewing.
8
‘Sátántangó’ (1994)
Directed by Béla Tarr
Recognized as one of the most extended non-experimental narrative films ever produced, Hungarian auteur Béla Tarr‘s Sátántangó spans an astonishing 7.5 hours. Describing this runtime as daunting is a vast understatement. The film unfolds at a deliberate pace, steeped in a dark atmosphere, probing into bleak philosophical themes while illuminating a community besieged by poverty and the indifference of humanity.
Completing Sátántangó is a Herculean task, and once achieved, the desire to repeat such an arduous experience is unlikely. Still, those who muster the courage to view it (often in one grueling sitting, though not always) frequently declare it one of the most unforgettable cinematic experiences they have ever encountered. The film is complex, beautifully crafted, and visually stunning, representing a dramatic epic that justifies every moment of its runtime. It is a truly transformative piece of art.
7
‘Grave of the Fireflies’ (1988)
Directed by Isao Takahata
In discussions surrounding emotionally harrowing war films, Grave of the Fireflies is an essential inclusion. As one of the earliest films produced by Studio Ghibli, its emotional impact is heightened by its basis in true events. It has long been regarded as one of the most heartbreaking animated films and a crucial war narrative from the 1980s.
Some films portray war as a hellish experience, while others, like Grave of the Fireflies, convey the same horrors through the innocent perspectives of children. This film stands out as one of the bleakest entries in the war genre, delivering a gripping examination of the profound losses inflicted not only by World War II but by military conflict as a whole. With its stunning animation and superb writing, Grave of the Fireflies exemplifies the pinnacle of anime filmmaking, leaving an indelible mark on its viewers.
6
‘Dancer in the Dark’ (2000)
Directed by Lars von Trier
Lars von Trier is often considered one of the most polarizing directors, known for crafting films that embody cynicism and profound sadness. When discussing his most impactful works, opinions vary widely; however, there is a consensus that his most heart-wrenching film is Dancer in the Dark. Starring Björk, this pitch-black musical may feature what could be considered the most remarkable performance by a singer in cinematic history.
This film is crucial for understanding the Dogme 95 movement, which von Trier co-founded alongside Thomas Vinterberg. With its exceptional music, deeply stirring narrative, and outstanding performances, Dancer in the Dark presents an overwhelming absence of hope or consolation, making the emotional experience challenging to endure more than once.
Dancer in the Dark
- Release Date
- October 6, 2000
- Runtime
- 140 Minutes
- Director
- Lars von Trier
5
‘Funny Games’ (1997)
Directed by Michael Haneke
Austrian director Michael Haneke is known for creating some of the most disturbing and emotionally challenging films ever made. Among his works, the original Funny Games stands out as one that few viewers are likely to want to experience a second time. Although Haneke also directed a highly praised American remake in 2007, the original remains unmatched.
It’s a movie that calls you out for enjoying it yet makes it impossible to look away, what with all the suspense, masterful character work, and jaw-dropping twists.
This clever, meta-analysis of violence and the audience’s appetite for it in media is embedded with a clear disdain for its viewers—a notion that curiously works in its favor. Funny Games forces viewers to confront their own enjoyment of violence while simultaneously holding them captive with its suspenseful plot, intricate character development, and shocking twists. Though rewatch value often plays a crucial role in determining a film’s potential as a cult classic, Funny Games has remained an essential cult favorite for decades.
4
‘Requiem for a Dream’ (2000)
Directed by Darren Aronofsky
Darren Aronofsky is renowned for his exploration of dark themes in cinema, often prioritizing style over substance. Nevertheless, he achieved a remarkable equilibrium in the masterful Requiem for a Dream, which could be considered the most potent anti-drug film ever produced.
Despite delivering strong messages and calls for action, Requiem for a Dream offers a deeply sympathetic examination of addiction and the circumstances that can lead individuals down that path. However, this does not mitigate the reality that it is an emotionally devastating film that audiences may not wish to revisit. The performances are extraordinary, highlighted by Ellen Burstyn‘s portrayal, which stands as one of the most heart-wrenching in cinematic history. Coupled with an exceptional score and flawless direction, the movie ultimately leaves viewers feeling profoundly shattered, making it unlikely for anyone to desire a second encounter.
3
‘Martyrs’ (2008)
Directed by Pascal Laugier
While cinephiles often revel in the thrill of horror films, appreciating the unique rush of fear they provoke, not all horror narratives are created equal. The French psychological horror film Martyrs stands as one of cinema’s most profoundly disturbing entries.
Exceedingly brutal and gruesome, Martyrs pushes the boundaries of horror cinema. It has been divisively categorized as “torture porn” by some, while others argue it serves as a penetrating critique of the genre and the reasons behind audiences’ fascination with violence. This intricate and thought-provoking film is sure to spark debate, yet most viewers would concur that nothing could compel them to relive the harrowing cruelty, violence, and sadistic gore depicted within its narrative.
<source media="(min-width: 0px)" data-srcset="https://static1.colliderimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/sharedimages/2024/07/martyrs-2008-film-poster.jpg?q=49&fit=crop
