Just like the latest fashion trends, teen mystery dramas maintain their timeless appeal. A perfect example is the inaugural season of Paramount+’s School Spirits, a captivating supernatural YA murder mystery that successfully builds upon the edgy narrative groundwork established by classic series such as Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Pretty Little Liars, and <em>Teen Wolf</em>. It even incorporates elements from the CBS sitcom Ghosts, while forging its own unique path. The series masterfully tackles the dark journey of its ghostly protagonist, ensuring a serious exploration of its themes without overwhelming viewers with despair. Instead, the show’s charming coming-of-age essence consistently shines through, making it a refreshing addition to a genre that can often feel saturated.
School Spirits emerged as a sleeper hit in the streaming arena, buoyed by overwhelmingly positive reviews, and its second season has retained all of the tender-hearted irreverence, captivating soap opera charm, and clever plot twists that fans loved. Created by siblings Megan and Nate Trinrud, alongside showrunner Oliver Goldstick (notably from Pretty Little Liars), Season 2 picks up immediately following the dramatic cliffhanger of the first season. It further deepens the lore surrounding the peculiar town of Split River and the unfortunate ghosts trapped within the confines of their high school?an existence that could easily be considered a living nightmare.
Discover the Intriguing Plot of ‘School Spirits’ Season 2
As the first season wrapped up, Maddie Nears (Peyton List) finally uncovered the shocking details surrounding her “death.” However, Season 2 swiftly reveals that resolving one mystery only leads to the emergence of another. The ghost of Janet Hamilton (Jess Gabor), once thought to be gone, has taken control of Maddie’s body and vanished. Meanwhile, their treacherous teacher, Mr. Martin (Josh Zuckerman), has also disappeared. Now, Maddie’s spirit is trapped within the Split River High grounds, continuing her role as an amateur detective, searching for clues about Janet and Mr. Martin. While Maddie’s unique circumstances create tension among her ghostly companions, her newfound friends remain committed to solving the case?though the loyalty of Simon Elroy (Kristian Ventura), Maddie’s best friend who can actually see her, remains uncertain.
In the meantime, the previously mysterious Janet’s backstory?particularly her connection to Mr. Martin?unfolds through flashbacks as she navigates life in Maddie’s body. As she grapples with past traumas and learns about the modern world, Janet experiences a taste of freedom for the first time in decades, perhaps even her entire life. Pursuing Janet are Nicole Herrera (Kiara Pichardo), Maddie’s friend from the living realm, and Claire Zomer (Rainbow Wedell), Maddie’s childhood best friend. However, after witnessing a terrifying act by the Janet-possessed Maddie, Nicole and Claire begin to suspect that the friend they once adored may be capable of committing heinous acts.
Experience the Best Moments from ‘School Spirits’ Season 1 in Season 2
School Spirits has retained its captivating essence in the second season, particularly in how it approaches intense themes with surprising depth. While it may not be as extreme as Euphoria, certain scenes still hit hard, which is fitting for a series centered on teenagers who have experienced untimely deaths and deep emotional scars. The individual struggles of the characters are presented in a way that feels authentic, steering clear of exploitation. Thanks to School Spirits‘ skillful use of the quirky elements characteristic of teen dramedies, the narrative avoids spiraling into melodrama or tedium.

Related
Missing ?School Spirits?? Explore This Eerie Horror Comedy Series Now Available for Streaming
Teenage milestones persist even in the afterlife.
This narrative framework is where School Spirits truly shines. Our teenage years are filled with emotions that feel like both the highest highs and the lowest lows. The series expertly balances silliness and lightheartedness with moments of turmoil and heartbreak. School Spirits captures this duality more authentically than many predecessors in its genre, allowing both extremes to coexist harmoniously. The strong ensemble cast continues to play a pivotal role in this success, and based on the first three episodes reviewed, each character receives their moment to shine. Milo Manheim‘s portrayal of Wally Clark, the jock with a heart of gold, remains a standout, showcasing how his genuine affection for Maddie keeps their budding romance alive. The show?s pacing ensures that there are moments of stillness, allowing the characters’ emotional complexities to resonate. Additionally, Charley (Nick Pugliese) experiences a sweet flirtation with fellow ghost and pottery enthusiast Yuri (Miles Elliot).
On the flip side, Rhonda (Sarah Yarkin) confronts her past trauma, reopening old wounds that she had previously tried to ignore. While this serious subject matter isn’t taken lightly, witnessing our beloved beatnik character reveal vulnerability adds depth to her development. New cast member Quinn (Ci Hang Ma), a band member at Split River High, integrates seamlessly into the established dynamic. In the living world, Nicole and Claire put aside their differences long enough to unite in the pursuit of Janet-Maddie, while Xavier’s storyline takes an unexpected twist that will keep viewers guessing.
‘School Spirits’ Season 2 Delivers Another Touchdown (Pun Intended)
In terms of powerhouse performances, School Spirits continues to excel, with Peyton List delivering a riveting portrayal, particularly as she juggles the complex roles of Maddie and Janet. List brilliantly shares scenes with newcomer Gabor, showcasing the emotional depth of both characters as they navigate their intertwined fates. Ventura and Yarkin maintain impressive emotional consistency throughout the series, ensuring that there is not a single weak performance among the cast.
Having screened three episodes out of the total eight of Season 2, it?s clear that while we don?t delve deeply into every character?s growth or resolve every intricate mystery immediately, these initial episodes provide a solid foundation for what lies ahead in the season. The quirky cast of Split River’s misfits may occasionally express that familiar teenage angst we all recognize, but their disagreements are simply part of the fabric of their ghostly family, proving that love and loyalty transcend even death.
School Spirits Season 2 is set to premiere on January 30 on Paramount+.
Watch on Paramount+
