Max’s The Penguin has finally unveiled its much-anticipated finale, delivering a powerful conclusion to the intricate story arcs of its primary characters. Among the standout performances, Colin Farrell’s exceptional interpretation of the notorious villain captures attention, yet it is Cristin Milioti’s portrayal of Sofia that truly captivates audiences with her compelling and emotionally charged storyline. Unfortunately, her tragic fate towards the climax of The Penguin has left fans feeling a profound sense of loss for this complex character. Nevertheless, the finale hints at an intriguing possibility of a partnership between Sofia and Zoe Kravitz’s Selina Kyle. In a recent interview, Cristin Milioti shared her thoughts on this development, hinting at an exciting potential meeting between these two half-sisters in the upcoming The Batman 2.

Exploring the Possibility of Sofia’s Crossover with Selina Kyle’s Catwoman in The Batman Part II

Milioti expressed her genuine desire to reprise her role as the unpredictable yet deeply flawed gangster in Matt Reeves’ much-awaited Batman sequel. She emphasized that a potential alliance between Sofia and her on-screen half-sister Selina Kyle could lead to thrilling and chaotic developments in the dark underbelly of Gotham City. This collaboration could not only deepen their characters but also enhance the storyline significantly.

During an engaging interview with The Direct, the How I Met Your Mother star shared her aspirations for returning as Sofia in future DC projects. She also elaborated on the exciting prospect of a team-up between Sofia and Selina Kyle, also known as Catwoman. Milioti’s enthusiasm for her character shines through as she contemplates what this collaboration might bring to the screen.

“I mean, it’s my wildest hope that I get to revisit her, because I’ve loved this role so immensely. It’s like, one of my favorite things I’ve ever gotten to do, and I’m just obsessed with her,” Milioti passionately expressed. Her connection to the character is palpable, and she conveys a strong desire to explore more of Sofia’s journey.

“And I think if [Sofia and Selina Kyle] were united, we would just really tear s— up. I don’t know how to say it…We would just like, burn it down. You know what I mean? In a fun way. I think we’d have a lot of fun,” she added, illustrating her vision of the dynamic energy that such a partnership could bring to the story. This playful yet fierce attitude hints at the intriguing possibilities their collaboration could unveil.

Milioti further suggested that if this collaboration were to materialize, it would involve the two characters facing off against formidable foes, including the Penguin and potentially even Batman himself. The stakes would be high, and the entertainment value could reach new heights with such engaging confrontations.

In the gripping final moments of The Penguin, Milioti’s Sofia receives an enigmatic letter after her abrupt return to Arkham Asylum. Shortly thereafter, viewers discover that the sender of this mysterious note is none other than Selina Kyle, adding another layer of intrigue and anticipation for the future.

The Batman Part 2 is set to hit theaters on October 2, 2026, promising fans an exciting continuation of the gripping narrative.

Originally reported by Apoorv Rastogi on SuperHeroHype.