Editor’s note: The below recap contains spoilers for Tracker Season 2 Episode 4.

Colter Shaw (Justin Hartley) and Reenie Green (Fiona Rene) finally set aside their phone calls to actually spend quality time together on Tracker in Season 2, Episode 4, titled “Noble Rot.” However, their much-anticipated reunion is quickly overshadowed by the urgency of a missing woman investigation. This week’s case takes them to a vineyard wellness retreat, where the discovery of hidden secrets leads to unexpected violence, turning an idyllic setting into a crime scene.

Colter Shaw Investigates a Corporate Kidnapping in ‘Tracker’ Season 2 Episode 4

The episode kicks off with a tense scene featuring a woman (Jessica Sutton) frantically navigating through grapevines under the cover of night, pursued by an unseen attacker. Fast forward to the next morning, Colter arrives in Napa Valley, tasked with unraveling the mystery of Quinn Ridgely, who has mysteriously vanished during a corporate leadership summit at the vineyard. As the owner of a software company, Quinn’s disappearance has sparked alarm, particularly since her wife Gray (Sofia Hirt) has offered a $50,000 reward for any information about her. Colter’s involvement is further motivated by his connection to a lawyer attending the retreat, making this case even more personal.

Reenie expresses skepticism about the notion of corporate kidnapping, a theory being floated by both the distraught wife and the venue’s security. The lack of any ransom note or demand supports her doubts, but after Colter conducts his initial inquiries, he begins to agree with her assessment. At Gray and Quinn’s villa, Colter observes signs of tension, including blankets on the couch that suggest the couple spent the night apart. Gray reveals a recent argument they had regarding the direction of their business, and Colter starts to suspect that the situation is more complex than a mere kidnapping. His hunches deepen when he meets William Locke (Neil Jackson), the estate owner, and Peter Reynolds (Roshawn Franklin), the head of security, both of whom seem evasive, raising Colter’s suspicions that they are concealing critical information.

As Colter and Reenie delve into the investigation, Reenie cleverly employs the strategy of charm to distract a security guard, allowing Colter to access the all-important CCTV footage. Their search yields shocking results: evidence that shows Quinn conversing with another individual just before her disappearance has mysteriously vanished from the records. This discovery leads them back to their earlier conversation with William Locke, who divulges that Quinn sought him out for “toad venom” for its psychoactive properties. Following a trail of clues, Colter tracks Quinn’s footsteps to a nearby construction site, where he finds her glasses abandoned in a boarded-up hole, reigniting fears of foul play and indicating that something sinister may indeed be afoot.

Uncovering the Vineyard’s Dark Secrets in ‘Tracker’ Season 2 Episode 4

As the investigation unfolds, Colter makes a shocking discovery—a severed human foot found in the hole where Quinn was last seen. This grim find indicates that the foot has been there for some time, suggesting it does not belong to Quinn. Colter hypothesizes that multiple bodies may have been buried at this construction site, intensifying the urgency of their investigation. They trace tire tracks leading to a maintenance shed, where Colter interviews a woman named Rona (Gloria Garayua) about the construction site and suspicious barrels that seem to have recently been relocated. After speaking with Rona, Colter has Bobby track her phone, leading to a critical location on the property, where Colter uncovers additional bodies concealed within barrels. The tension escalates as a confrontation occurs when Colter is attacked by a man, but he manages to gain the upper hand, uncovering Jesse Pardue as the architect behind these horrific acts.

As the plot thickens, it becomes clear that Quinn was indeed kidnapped by Jesse and Rona. A series of unfortunate events led Quinn to accidentally stumble upon the construction crew’s dark secret—hidden bodies of migrant workers who perished in various accidents over the years. This revelation takes the episode in a chilling direction. While Colter and Reenie race against time to locate Quinn, she finds herself bound at another job site belonging to Jesse, desperately negotiating for her life. Offering both company funds and personal savings, Quinn’s situation becomes increasingly precarious as Jesse realizes Colter is closing in on him. With the clock ticking, Jesse decides that eliminating Quinn is the best way to protect his sinister secrets.

The hostage situation reaches a critical point when Colter arrives, aided by quick-thinking assistance from Velma (Abby McEnany). In a dramatic turn of events, Rona shifts alliances and shoots Jesse, allowing Quinn to escape. This escape sequence takes a dark turn as Jesse, in a desperate attempt to retaliate, stumbles backward into a woodchipper, where the audience witnesses the graphic consequences of his actions. It’s a surprisingly brutal moment for CBS, yet it underscores the gravity of the situation. Ultimately, Quinn emerges safe, and Colter successfully completes his mission.

Exploring Reenie’s New Romantic Interest in ‘Tracker’ Season 2 Episode 4

On a more personal note, Reenie brings a plus-one to the corporate summit, ensuring her own romantic entanglement amidst the chaos. If Colter is exploring potential relationships, it’s only fair that Reenie does, too. She shares that she has been in contact with a former coworker named Elliott Rush (Michael Rady) and introduces him to Colter. Their budding romance feels fresh and exciting, although they remain somewhat reserved with each other, likely due to the ongoing demands of the summit. The atmosphere of the getaway, originally intended for relaxation, becomes overshadowed as the search for Quinn intensifies, stealing moments away from their developing connection.

As Colter reflects on Reenie’s new relationship, he can’t help but inquire about her recent dinner with Russell (Jensen Ackles). Reenie appears pleasantly surprised that Colter even noticed, although she clarifies that Russell isn’t the type to be a romantic plus-one. This is precisely why she invited Elliott to join her. Reenie emphasizes that her relationship with Elliott is purely platonic at this stage. Nevertheless, Colter playfully teases her about whether Elliott’s wine tastings and yoga sessions align with her personality. Their banter reveals a deeper understanding of each other, especially when Reenie counters Colter’s teasing by pointing out that he hasn’t shared any details about his rendezvous with Billie from the previous week.

In the closing moments of the episode, Reenie bids farewell to Colter, delivering his payment while he relaxes with a beer amidst the vineyard’s chaos. Elliott commends Colter on his impressive work, mentioning that he has heard a great deal about him. With a bittersweet smile, Colter expresses hope that Elliott recognizes how fortunate he is to have Reenie. The scene captures a poignant moment, highlighting that despite their complex feelings, both Colter and Reenie are content in their current circumstances, understanding that their paths may diverge for now but could converge again in the future.

Tracker airs on CBS on Sundays at 8 PM ET and is available for next-day streaming on Paramount+.

Only a missing person would get Colter Shaw to a wine tasting.

Pros

• It’s great to see Reenie and Colter on screen together.
• Colter gets out of his comfort zone.
• The twists and turns in the episode are truly unexpected.

Cons

• Not enough Velma and Bobby! The team needs their own retreat STAT.

<