Once a dominant force in Hollywood, the Western genre experienced a significant decline in popularity during the late 1970s. However, the emergence of neo-Westerns such as Yellowstone, Justified, and Outer Range has reignited interest in stories that celebrate the indomitable spirit of the American frontier. Nearly twenty years ago, Into the West captivated audiences with its poignant exploration of this era, blending real and fictional characters against the backdrop of pivotal historical events. The series, released in a weekly format, ensured that viewers eagerly anticipated each episode’s emotional twists. It’s disheartening that <em>American Primeval</em> is not given a similar chance to become a centerpiece of conversation, especially as Netflix launches what appears to be one of the standout series of 2025.

Set against the tumultuous backdrop of 1857, American Primeval delves into a less-explored period of American history with remarkable depth. While many narratives from this time focus on the struggles between westward-bound settlers and the Indigenous nations defending their lands, this series introduces a less-discussed element: the early settlers from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The tension surrounding the Utah War (1857-1858), often overshadowed by the American Civil War, provides a rich context for the gripping tale penned by Mark L. Smith of The Revenant fame and directed by Peter Berg of Painkiller and The Leftovers. Unlike many traditional Westerns that center around male protagonists, American Primeval innovatively shifts its focus to three lead actresses, illustrating the harsh realities faced by women in the rugged American West.

Explore the Pivotal Role of Women in ‘American Primeval’

At the core of American Primeval lies the compelling story of Sara Rowell, portrayed by Betty Gilpin, and her son Devin, played by Preston Mota. Sara is fleeing a tumultuous past marked by violence in Philadelphia, seeking the promise of a new life on the frontier where her husband, and Devin’s father, has established a homestead in Crook Springs. The shadows of her past reveal that Sara is more than capable of defending herself; however, she still faces the grim reality of being a woman alone in an era when women were often considered the property of men. To navigate the treacherous frontier, Sara must rely on the guidance and generosity of others—a rare commodity in such a lawless and unforgiving landscape.

After a harrowing escape from the Mountain Meadows Massacre, Sara and Devin find refuge under the watchful care of Isaac Reed, portrayed by Taylor Kitsch. As a rugged loner burdened by his traumas, Isaac embodies the series’ emotional core. While he initially displays indifference to Sara and Devin’s plight, their life-or-death situation transforms his perspective. This dynamic is pivotal; it highlights how their fates intertwine, illustrating that they each require strength from one another. Their relationship evolves, becoming a central theme that enriches the narrative fabric of American Primeval.

Abish, played by Saura Lightfoot-Leon, emerges as another crucial character. As the new wife of Jacob Pratt, a Mormon settler heading west to join Brigham Young in modern-day Salt Lake City, Abish’s journey is anything but ordinary. While her faith and affection for Jacob exist, it becomes clear that she does not conform to the expectations of a submissive wife. Her persistent challenges to Jacob’s unwavering commitment to their beliefs reveal her inner strength and dissatisfaction with their forced marriage. In a time when options for young women were severely limited, Abish’s struggle resonates deeply. Her quest for freedom takes an unexpected turn during the massacre, leading to her capture by the Shoshone. Here, she encounters a surprising twist of fate that alters her trajectory and offers her a chance at empowerment.

Two Moons, portrayed by Shawnee Pourier, is another critical character woven into the narrative. After avenging herself against her rapist, she is compelled to flee her village, seeking a new existence. Her journey leads her to join Sara and Devin’s covered wagon as they venture westward. Despite the barriers of language, Two Moons forges a connection with Sara and Isaac, demonstrating resilience and adaptability. Throughout the six episodes, American Primeval skillfully intertwines the stories of these three women, each confronting formidable challenges indicative of their time. Their determination and resourcefulness shine through, emphasizing that while they draw strength from the men in their lives, it is ultimately their stories that elevate the series into a remarkable viewing experience.

Challenge Your Perspectives with ‘American Primeval’

American Primeval moves at a relentless pace, covering approximately five hours of gripping storytelling across its six episodes. The series lives up to its TV-MA rating, not solely due to the intense bloodshed evident in the epic shootouts and chaotic massacres but also because the female characters endure historically accurate brutality at the hands of men. Witnessing their struggles is heartbreaking, yet it starkly reminds viewers of the perilous reality faced by women on the frontier, even when circumstances appear favorable.

Furthermore, the series’ portrayal of Mormons, particularly Brigham Young, is strikingly harsh. Kim Coates delivers a phenomenal performance, embodying a character that emerges as a deeply sinister presence. While historical narratives often downplay the darker aspects of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, American Primeval challenges this tendency, urging viewers to confront their own misconceptions about the church’s actions on the American frontier. The series compels audiences to reassess whether polygamy was the most egregious aspect of their beliefs, as Jacob spirals into madness, fueled by his fanatical convictions after Abish’s abduction.

Although elements concerning the Shoshone Nation may occasionally feel discordant, American Primeval has enlisted the expertise of Julie O’Keefe, an Indigenous Cultural Consultant from the Osage Nation, to ensure authentic representation. Collaborating with Indigenous artisans, the series showcases the Shoshone villages with genuine cultural nuances. Although each Indigenous character is well-developed and integral to the plot, they remain intertwined with the overarching narratives of Sara and Abish, lacking standalone storylines. While American Primeval presents a more compelling narrative than many Westerns, it ultimately neglects to provide Indigenous characters with independent arcs.

Why ‘American Primeval’ Deserves a Weekly Release Schedule

From the very first episode, American Primeval captivates viewers, drawing them into the survival struggles of its core characters, even when the narrative hints at their tragic fates. With a rich ensemble cast, including the likes of Shea Whigham, Joe Tippett, Jai Courtney, Kyle Bradley Davis, Lucas Neff, and Shawnee Pourier, the series balances its storytelling across multiple characters in just six episodes.

Rather than relying on flashy visual effects or extravagant settings, American Primeval grounds itself in the gritty humanity of its characters and environments. As the series progresses, it reveals the unexpected bond that forms between Isaac and Sara, fundamentally altering their identities. The chemistry between Kitsch and Gilpin is palpable, showcasing their characters’ strengths and flaws in a masterful display of acting, direction, and writing.

It is unfortunate that American Primeval is not receiving a weekly release schedule, as it embodies the characteristics of event television while being constrained by the binge-watching model. The real loss lies in the fact that Smith and Berg have crafted a series that is both brilliant and prestigious, yet may go unnoticed by many. This show has the potential to reignite interest in the Western genre in Hollywood, allowing creators the freedom to explore the nuanced aspects of America’s often-neglected history.

All six episodes of American Primeval are currently available for streaming on Netflix.